Cadillac Margarita Recipe (Top-Shelf) - Evolving Table (2024)

This Cadillac Margarita recipe is all the name implies, the best you can get. To make this top-shelf drink, you only need a few ingredients like reposado tequila, Grand Marnier, fresh lime juice, and agave nectar. Impress your guests with this decadent Mexican co*cktail at your next Cinco de Mayo party or get-together.

It’s safe to say that there really isn’t a bad margarita out there.

But, there definitely are BETTER recipes, and this Cadillac Margarita is one of them!

Similar to a classic margarita, you need tequila, orange liquor, and lime juice. However, rather than tequila blanco, you need tequila reposado. Agave syrup tastes better and is healthier for you than sour mix, as well.

But unlike the classic, this one is made with premium ingredients.

Top shelf tequila reposado.

Grand Marnier instead of Cointreau or other orange liqueur.

And just the right amount of agave nectar to balance out that freshly squeezed lime juice.

And fair warning… Because the flavors are so well balanced, these guys are secretly incredibly potent!

Not to mention, it only takes 4 ingredients and less than 5 minutes to whip one up. So they’re the perfect addition to your upcoming Cinco de Mayo celebration or girls’ night in!

(If you want a little more of a fruity flavor, you’ve got to check out this Blood Orange Margarita!)

Ingredients

You only need a few simple ingredients to make this Cadillac Margarita:

• Tequila. Opt for a reposado, which has been aged longer and has a slightly sweeter flavor than a blanco. However, it doesn’t have that whiskey flavor from being aged too long, as anejos do. Pick a good quality tequila since it makes up the bulk of the flavor. Some of my favorites include Lunazul, Espolon, and Cazadores. These brands are all roughly $20 for a 750ml – delivering tons of flavor without a hefty price tag.
• Lime juice. Freshly squeezed is best. You need roughly 1 lime to get enough juice for one margarita. Use a citrus juicer or lemon squeezer to get the most liquid out.
• Grand Marnier. Elevates the flavors of this drink. This is a higher-quality French orange liqueur. It is slightly more expensive with a more complex taste than Triple Sec and Cointreau.
• Agave nectar. You don’t need much, just a couple of teaspoons. You can also sub honey or even regular sugar, but agave gives it the most authentic flavor. Agave also mixes in much more easily than honey which tends to harden and crystallize once cold.

How to Make a Cadillac Margarita

The easy steps to make this Cadillac Margarita take only a few minutes. See the recipe card for more detailed ingredient amounts.

Juice and Mix

Roll your lime on the counter back and forth a couple of times. This step releases the juice and makes it easier to get everything out.

Cut your limes in half. Use a citrus juicer or lemon squeezer if you have one. It’s ok if you don’t, but it will take a little more work. Squeeze over a clean bowl.

Add ice to a co*cktail shaker or glass mason jar with a lid until halfway full. Pour in whatever type of tequila you are using, Grand Marnier, lime juice, and agave nectar. Place the lid on tightly.

Shake it Good

Shake the container well for a minute or two. If you are using a co*cktail shaker, hold the top on tight so it doesn’t come off.

Salt the Rim

If you want that restaurant-quality margarita at home, then you’ve GOT to give it a salted rim!

Cut a small slit in the middle of a lime slice. Then, rub the lime around the rim of the empty glass, about ½ inch down the side.

Pour some coarse or kosher salt onto a small plate or bowl. Lightly dip the rim of the glass into the salt until the rim is completely coated.

Pour and Serve

Remove the lid from your shaker. If you have a strainer, use it to eliminate any chunks of lime.

Carefully pour the margarita into your salted glass. Garnish with a slice of lime or orange peel and enjoy!

Meal Prep and Storage

• To Prep-Ahead: Squeeze lime juice up to 1-2 days ahead of time and store in an airtight container.
• To Store: Keep any unused margarita (if there is any!) in a jar with a tightly fitting lid. Leave in the fridge for up to 2-3 days.

Make a Big Batch

Cadillac Margaritas are delicious when made in small batches for one or two. However, you can easily whip up a batch for a group.

If you would like to make this recipe to serve 8 people:

• Increase the amount of tequila to 1 ½ cups, Grand Marnier to 1 cup, lime juice to ¾ cup, and agave nectar to ½ cup.
• Add all ingredients to a large pitcher without ice and whisk to combine.
• Store margarita covered in the refrigerator for up to 2 days.
• Add ice 5-10 minutes before serving and enjoy!

FAQs

Expert Tips and Tricks

• Reach up. For the Cadillac Margarita, opt for a top-shelf tequila and aim for reposado for the most flavor.
• Opt for fresh. The hand-squeezed lime juice will make a huge difference in the quality of the margarita.
• Shake well. Don’t under-mix the co*cktail. Shake until the mixer is very cold on the outside.
• Don’t skip the salt. A salted rim is a must for this premium drink.
• All decked out. Garnishes make for a beautiful presentation. Opt for a slice of lime or orange.

More co*cktail Recipes

If you love this Cadillac Margarita, try one of these other co*cktail recipes next:

• Creamy Frozen Mojito
• Piña Colada
• Pomegranate Martini
• Frozen Peach White Wine Sangria
• Mexican 75